Posted by
Pscyclone on Thursday, January 10, 2008 10:36:55 AM
.. and the audience of "The View" joined in with laughter.
In an interesting condemnation of most religions, Joy Behar remarked, "I have a theory that you can’t find any saints anymore because of psychotropic medication. I think that [in] the old days, the saints were hearing voices and they didn’t have any Thorazine to calm them down.
"Now that we have all of this medication available to us, you can’t find a saint anymore."
It became clear in the crosstalk that Ms. Behar was referring to the Catholic Church and its methods and standards for canonization.
What Ms. Behar did was show the depth and breadth of her ignorance. Saints are not canonized because they hear voices; rather, they are canonized because they lived their lives in such a way that would allow them to be lifted up as examples of a Christian walk, where faith in God is not only necessary, but also sane. The saints are proof for the rest of us that there is a better way of living – which begins and ends with God.
However, if you look at what she said closely, doesn’t it appear that she’s insulting not just the Catholics, but Jews and Muslims as well? Sure, Judaism and Islam don’t refer to their hero figures as "saints", but in a religious context it is rather the same thing, whatever doctrinal name a religion uses, no?
It is well known that Islam’s principle "saint" Muhammad often "communed" with Allah over a vast array of subjects, not the least of which was the question of whether to wed and consummate the wedding with a nine year-old girl, or not; Allah approved. Muhammad sought – and found – Allah’s voice in just about every decision we understand he made (as recorded by the Qur’an). The origination of Islam is, of course, the appearance of the angel Gabriel, personally delivering Allah’s first recruitment message to Muhammad. Does Ms. Behar believe this appearance would never happen had Muhammad been on a regimen of Thorazine? Doesn't it then follow if Muhammad had not received and accepted the Allah's recruitment as a "saint" that the modern world might never have known the Islamic faith?
I wonder how the Muslim community would have responded had they chosen to take Ms. Behar’s remarks at face value instead of joining in the mocking of a competing faith.